Most of the feedback our first draft received was really positive, with lots of people noting that the video is interesting and that they did not get bored watching it - I was extremely happy with this, as the main aim for our video was to create something people had not really seen before. Additionally, there was a lot of praise for our performances, which again made me happy as good characterisation was essential in our video and we seemed to have pulled it off well.
Positive comments:
"Good TV effect"
"First effect looks good - really trippy"
"Characterisation + acting was perfect"
"Transitions between each shot flows - ghosting effect matches trippy theme"
"Extremely interesting - never got bored"
"Love your mise en scene a LOT"
Constructive criticism mainly consisted of people noting that one of the shots nearer the end went on for too long and needed a cut somewhere, which I agree with. Additionally, some said the kaleidoscope effect at the start needed to be cut down slightly.
There were also a few notes that suggested editing some of Phoebe's shots in order to heighten the contrast and brightness, which is a goal of mine for the final draft.
Critical comments:
"Take out the background noise" (an editing slip)
"Shots of Phoebe going crazy could be broken up with some quick (sped-up) shots in between"
"Could sharpen some parts"
"Some editing needs to be cut more suddenly with the music"
"Needs more shots of Lucy|"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
Carol Vernallis is known for her theory based on music video editing. The 4 key concepts she discusses are: Narrative Editing Camera move...
-
Andrew Goodwin discusses six different conventions or music videos. 1. Goodwin states that there is a relationship between the lyrics and ...
-
This is a music video revolving around a specific narrative - it shows a main character (the lead singer) wanting to enter a dance competi...
No comments:
Post a Comment